Butter Cream Cupcakery Review

A review of the experience of Butter Cream Cupcakery written by Sheree Schwarz.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Dietary Options:
- Gluten Free

Location

address1: 3663 S College Ave
city: Fort Collins
state: CO
postalCode: 80525
latitude: 40.536827
longitude: -105.077157

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(970) 225-1040

The Reviews

Written By: Marissa McAllister

We had Butter Cream Cupcakery do cupcakes for our wedding - and they were AMAZING! The tasting was so fun and delicious. I had never had their cupcakes before and they were like heaven sent! They were able to make about 300 mini cupcakes (only 6 inch - that’s about the size of a muffin top) so we could have a variety of flavors. They even were able to make red velvet vegan (which is incredibly hard to do)! We had a ton of flavors to choose from. They were all so delicious that it was hard to choose! Luckily we had a few leftover so we were able to taste a few more flavors. They were even able to save us a few cupcakes by making some vegan icing and putting it in the mini cupcakes for us. They also made us a vegan and gluten free cake so we could cut a cake and still be mostly vegan/gluten free. This cake was the best cake I’ve ever had. It was soft, delicious, and not too sweet. It had a light buttercream frosting that was not too sugary. They really were amazing and able to do an amazing job!

Written By: Karlotte Ballard

Our wedding was 3 days ago and I cant put into words how amazing our cake and cupcakes were!! The hardest decision to make was picking which flavor we wanted. Our cake was half naked with raspberry and I believe its called something else?(I cant remember what it is called) and we added a cupcake flavor to our order. We also decided to do cake pops in a couple flavors and we also added another cupcake flavor. Our guest absolutely loved all of it and could not stop talking about it. People were trying to take cake home with them and we had to tell them it was all gone. I was also so glad that they had the cupcakes set up for us in a cupcake tower just the way I wanted them. I could go on and on about how delicious everything was but I know you all are dying to see pictures so…Here you go! (I also just noticed the guy in the last picture has a cupcake flavor that we added to our order!(I love this company))