A Piece of Cake Review

A review of the experience of A Piece of Cake written by Edy Wallace.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Cakes & Desserts:
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Delivery & Setup

Location

address1: 117 Great Brook Rd
city: New Milford
state: CT
postalCode: 06776
latitude: 41.600374
longitude: -73.387147

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(860) 350-8255

The Reviews

Written By: Edy Wallace

A Piece of Cake was one of the preferred vendors for our venue. I was worried that since we were getting married at a yacht club, many of our vendors would be yacht club vendors. A Piece of Cake was one of the few vendors that did not use the yacht club for their own storage, but still managed to deliver amazing desserts to our venue.

From the first tasting, I knew I could trust them to deliver. They made selections of cakes, fillings, and frostings for us to mix and match to make our own custom cake. They were very helpful with suggestions on combinations and serving amounts. They were very helpful in assisting us in our goal to have a small cutting cake and still have the top tier for our first anniversary. They were helpful in suggesting ways to store the top tier so it will be good for our anniversary.

They were very helpful in delivering the cake to the venue on time.

The cake was beautiful. It exceeded my expectations for taste, looks, and decoration. It was delivered on time and in perfect condition.

Our guests loved the cake. It was gone by the time we reached the dance floor!

I would recommend them to any bride without hesitation. Thank you for making our dessert experience so memorable!

Written By: Joletta Duffy

We have been frequent visitors to A Piece of Cake since it opened. When we began planning our wedding, we knew right away that we wanted A Piece of Cake to do our cake. We have always loved their cakes and have seen their designs on all sorts of different cakes and cupcakes. When we went in to do our tasting, we were pleasantly surprised to find out that we could have as many flavors as we wanted to try! We ended up choosing 3 flavors and did half chocolate cake with Oreo Filling, half almond cake with raspberry buttercream and lemon filling, and half white cake with strawberry filling and whipped cream!) We also got to customize the look of our cake to our exact specifications! The cake was so amazing and we have gotten so many compliments on it! We were so excited to eat it again on our wedding day! The cake was even more beautiful than we had imagined! We were very impressed with the design they came up with and the fact that they were able to create a 3-D topper that looked exactly like the one on the cover of their cookbook! Their customer service was wonderful and they have an amazing team there! We hope to have many more cakes created with them! We can’t wait to have our cake again in a year!

Written By: Blancha Whitaker

We went to A Piece Of Cake because they are the bakery of choice for our caterer. I should say up front that I usually do not like cake. This is a very good cake. It was still good after being frozen and thawed out, the week before the wedding. So in addition to it being tasty, it also was not going to be a big hit with me because I do not like cake that much. However this cake was so good, that even though I usually do not like cake, I thought it was amazing. It was very flavorful, and the frosting was very good as well. The other thing that made it a great cake was the fact that we were able to do different flavors in all the tiers of the cake. We were also able to have a different flavor for every layer of the cupcakes. Another plus was the fact that they do not try to tell you what you should do for your wedding. They are very laid back and open to what you want to do. They do not believe in doing tiered cakes because they think it is not very attractive. They do, however have very nice tasting samples for you to try out different flavors with different fillings. They are very down to earth and not like a watery cake. They are very generous with the samples, and they do not make you feel rushed. They were very accommodating and made sure we got exactly what we wanted. They also made sure that the cake was delivered on time. They really just want you to be happy, and they leave it up to you to decide how you want your cake to look. I thought the cake was very nice, and was very tasty. I also really appreciate that they do not want to tell you how to run your wedding. They just want you to be happy and to know that you can do whatever you want, and if you have a different idea than what they had in mind, they will work with you. To top it off, they are very affordable. I thought they were a great vendor and would recommend them to anyone that wants a very good cake that does not try to tell you how to do your wedding, and that is very affordable.