Bake Me A Cake Review

A review of the experience of Bake Me A Cake written by Savina Wyatt.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Cakes & Desserts:
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom’s Cakes
Price Range:
- $$ – Affordable

Location

address1: 710 Orange Ave.
city: Altamonte Springs
state: FL
postalCode: 32714
latitude: 28.661835
longitude: -81.411681

Service Area: Central Florida

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(407) 830-9006

The Reviews

Written By: Savina Wyatt

We had a great experience with Bake Me a Cake! They were easy to work with and let us do a tasting with a variety of flavors. The cake was moist and flavorful. My husband and I are chocoholics and had our hearts set on a chocolate cake on our wedding day. They surprised us with a chocolate wedding cake that was delicious! We also had a variety of mini desserts that our guests loved. On our wedding day, the cake was delivered on time and was exactly what we had envisioned. The desserts were placed all around our venue area so our guests could enjoy them as they wished. Bake Me a Cake provided great service, a delicious cake/desserts, and a great value for our wedding. They are a must-hire if you are looking for something delicious and memorable for your wedding day!

Written By: Kary Denton

We went to the bake shop about 6 months before our wedding for a cake tasting and WOW! the cakes were all delicious! We had a hard time choosing flavors! We decided on key lime and guava! We got a 3-tier cake and chose the decor, we were going to have our initials on it as a surprise for our mother. The initial pattern was all that was left of the initial was SO beautiful! We were very happy with the decor of the cake and the flavors! We even brought some home to try with our family! About 2 weeks before the wedding, we found out our venue had a connection with the bake shop and asked them to also do the cake tasting! That was even better because we got to do it again! The cake flavors were all amazing again and the same as the first time we went in the shop! We were so excited to have our cake again at our wedding! The cake was so soft and delicious! The initial pattern was perfect and the surprise for our mother was beautiful! Our wedding was small and we didn’t have a cake just yet so we had brought home some leftovers and ate it for days! They are so good! We didn’t get a chance to have the cake at our wedding but we had a piece of it in a bottle of key lime and wow! It was delicious! The shop is so cute and the ladies are so nice and helped us make a cake design that worked well with our cake topper! We LOVE this bake shop! We recommend them to everyone! We didn’t have a piece of our cake at our wedding but we made sure to eat our top layer! We couldn’t resist!

Written By: Pamella Shea

We loved Bake Me a Cake. They made our vision come to life. Our cake was a beautiful 4 tier cake with the most delicious flavors. Each layer had it’s own unique flavor that was not overpowering. We had the best experience tasting with bake me a cake. The owner shared many of his cakes and fillings with us and was patient with all our questions. He was the first person to actually answer our question about using our own custom wedding colors. We had the best time wedding planning with his help. On our wedding day we had the best time at our cake tasting and wedding dress fittings. We loved bake me a cake so much we had them make our cake forpht for us as well and we had a mini cake for our 1 year wedding anniversary. We loved having our own little cake to eat in a year. It was so good. We look forward to having another mini cake in a year. Thank you for making our day so special.

Written By: Anstice Dawson

Bake Me A Cake is a small, family owned business that serves the area known as the Villages, which is a large retirement community in southeastern Florida. My husband and I are not from the area, but after reviewing their extensive list of cake flavors, we decided to try one of them. We chose Tiramisu, which we really love and which is a well known flavor. We contacted the owner, Sharon, and told her what we wanted. She told us that the flavor would be their Chocolate Mocha Docking, which is a flavor they have that is different from their normal flavors. We decided on a 4 layer cake with different flavors in each layer. The cake itself was beautiful, decorated exactly as we had specified, and tasted wonderful. The flavor was so good that we decided to have all four tiers, or 8 flavors, instead of having just one docking flavor. The second and third tiers were Picasso and Tiramisu, the fourth and fifth tiers were their white cake with raspberry, their chocolate with Kahlua, their almond with ameretto, and their lemon with lemon. All of the flavors were as wonderful as the first tier, which was their white cake with raspberry filling. We received many compliments on the flavor and the cake was beautiful. We would highly recommend Bake Me A Cake for any occasion, and hope we get the opportunity to use them again.