Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery Review

A review of the experience of Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery written by Rebecka Page.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: 2034 17th St
city: Columbus
state: IN
postalCode: 47201
latitude: 39.215827
longitude: -85.901847

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(812) 372-7437

The Reviews

Written By: Rebecka Page

I have so many things to say about this cake! It was amazing! It was delicious! We did cupcakes for the guests and they were a hit! People were coming up to us and telling us how much they loved them! The decorations were amazing! I even asked her to make some flowers to go on the top. I told her my wedding colors were purple and gold. She said she was sure that she can do that! I am not a fan of frosting but this was so good I could eat a whole bowl of it! The cake was moist and the cupcakes were amazing! The best part was the price! It was the best price I could find for the amount of cake I wanted. I am so happy I found her! If you want a delicious cake, at an amazing price, then go see Heidi and her famly! They will not let you down! I highly recommend them!

Written By: Mignonne Wooten

Jim did such a great job on our cakes! He was able to do a combination of 2 cakes for ours. We had a smallish cake made out of chocolate and vanilla with a peanut butter filling with a outer chocolate cake. It was such a hit! We also had a large traditional cake made out of vanilla with lemon filling and a raspberry preserve filling. The best lemon cake I have ever had. Both flavors were so delicious that we barely had enough to serve all our guests. Our guests loved it so much that they wanted to try both flavors which is funny because they are not traditional cake flavors. My husband and I loved our cakes so much that we ate the leftover cake for a week after the wedding (that’s how good it was!). Now we can’t wait for our anniversary to eat the top layer. Thank you so much Jim!!!

Written By: Hortense Davidson

I was referred to Cakes by Ahlemeyer by a friend of mine and I am so happy that was the case because their cake was delicious! Before we even had a chance to visit with them, they sent us a beautiful sample with five different flavors of cupcakes. It was so hard to choose which flavors to have at our wedding because they were all so good! The staff that we worked with were so helpful and were able to answer any and all questions we had. They offered to make a special all-white cake for our wedding, but we wanted some very specific designs on the side of the cake. They made the design we wanted and it turned out beautiful! On the day of the wedding, the cake was delivered to the venue and it was more beautiful than I could’ve imagined! Not only did it look great, but it was also very tasty! My parents also bought a smaller cake from them for my bridal shower!

Written By: Fidelia Anthony

As soon as we got engaged we knew there was no question we would be eating cake at our wedding - it’s just part of the package when you get married at the Hotel Florence. We had the option to choose between two vendors and picked Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery because of the great reviews. We tried cake samples (they provide four samples) and picked vanilla with strawberries and cream for the main cake and chocolate with cookies and cream for the groom’s cake. The samples were delicious. Months went by and we heard nothing. We emailed and called several times. Finally they told us they were ready when we told them we were going to use another baker (because we wanted something different - we didn’t want their cake). When we picked their cake up (we needed a grownup to help), we tried to give them the supplies (a sheet cake and a dummy cake) needed to make the groom’s cake and they told us they preferred we make the cake ourselves. We didn’t want to do that (what if we messed it up) so we decided to just pick another day (they had on their schedule Friday). It was the day before, and we didn’t hear anything. We emailed and called again. Finally they told us they were going to charge us extra for the different flavors (the samples were vanilla with cream cheese icing and chocolate with cookies and cream - it was delicious) and they also wanted $100 for the dummy cake. We were able to get the cake we wanted (chocolate with cookies and cream) for only $50 extra. The cake was so good and we had lots of compliments. The day before your wedding, you don’t need to worry about anything - but on Friday, a cake arrived with supplies needed for the dummy cake and they wanted $100 (this was in emails - we were charged $100 at the store). It didn’t end up getting delivered until the day AFTER your wedding (because of traffic and a holiday). So, two cakes didn’t show up (one for the wedding and one for the rehearsal), but they got delivered on a Sunday (our wedding was on a Saturday). The dummy cake was for the rehearsal (we wanted to have a cookie cake with a cowboy hat). Luckily, my parents were there and helped to cut up the cowboy hat and put it on top of the cake (this was on a table in the ballroom where everyone was) and then we all had cake (my husband and I cut up the groom’s cake and shared it - it was delicious). Overall, it was good but we were charged a lot extra and we had a busy wedding (we had lots going on).