Buttermilk Baking Company Review

A review of the experience of Buttermilk Baking Company written by Nanni Proctor.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Price Range:
- $$$ – Moderate

Location

address1: 3 Liberty Street
city: Newburyport
state: MA
postalCode: 01950
latitude: 42.811238
longitude: -70.869565

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(978) 499-8278

The Reviews

Written By: Nanni Proctor

We had a great experience with Buttermilk Baking Company for our wedding cake. We had the pleasure of working with Chris who helped us every step of the way. He provided us with many different options and designs to choose from. He was so helpful and generous! We ended up going with a three tiered cake, but weren’t sure if we wanted it to be more or less. Chris was very reassuring and explained that we could have three different flavors. We ended up going with orange poppy seed cake with an orange citrus buttercream, chocolate with chocolate gnash with a peanut butter buttercream, and strawberry with strawberry jam with a strawberry buttercream. We had so much fun tasting all the different flavors and combinations! On our wedding day, our cake was exactly what we wanted and even had our dog pictured on it! It was such a beautiful cake and we got so many compliments. We highly recommend them!

Written By: Iris Wheeler

We used Buttermilk Baking Company for our wedding cake. We heard about them from my Uncle, who lives near their home town and loves to eat at their restaurant. He told us they make some of the best desserts in New England, and offered to let us sample some of their cake and frosting options for our wedding cake. We chose 3 flavors of cake and each slice was better than the next! They were so helpful in helping us choose how many layers, what flavors and even helped us design a cake that was perfect for us. Since we had so many different flavors it was hard to choose a favorite but the pistachio and orange chocolate were to die for! The cake was moist, fluffy and fresh. It was delivered on time to the venue and they decorated it with the flowers from the wedding and placed all the extra cake flowers in a vase for the bride and groom to enjoy after the wedding. They were easy to get ahold of and helpful to work with. They are amazing bakers who make amazing desserts. I highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for a wedding cake in the New England area, or anyone who needs a dessert for any occasion! I already want to order some more cupcakes and desserts from them!