Betty Kay Bake Shop Review

A review of the experience of Betty Kay Bake Shop written by Bessie Hamrick.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Cakes & Desserts:
- Cake Accessories:
  - Cake Stands
  - Cake Toppers
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom’s Cakes
Dietary Options:
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Nut Free
- Sugar Free
- Vegan
Price Range:
- $$ – Affordable

Location

address1: 49 Liberty Street
city: Bath
state: NY
postalCode: 14810
latitude: 42.335053
longitude: -77.318245

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(607) 776-4842

The Reviews

Written By: Bessie Hamrick

When we decided to have a wedding, we didn’t know where to start. We were recently married, and this was the first important decision we had to make. We decided to have a small wedding, invite about 30 people, and have desserts provided by local vendors. One of those desserts would be cake. We didn’t know much about wedding cake, but we knew what we wanted. We went to several cake vendors in the area, but no one seemed to fit our idea of a wedding cake. Then we met with Betty Kay, and instantly we were at ease. She was so nice, and she created the wedding cake of our dreams. We had four different flavors, and the decor was exactly what we were looking for. Our friends and family couldn’t stop raving about the cake. We had your standard white wedding cake with buttercream frosting, but we also had a lemon, chocolate with raspberry filling, and spice cake with cream cheese frosting. We had your standard almond cup or your standard chocolate mousse cups, but we also had your standard chocolate cups filled with cookies and cream. What made everything so great was that all four flavors were GREAT. All the flavors worked well together, and each person could find something to their liking. Betty Kay made everything so easy, and she was very accommodating. We had a small wedding, but we wanted all of our guests to enjoy dessert. The desserts were the perfect size, and everyone loved them. They were also the perfect flavor, big enough to taste the filling but not too rich. Everything was perfect, and it was all because of you. Thank you for creating the perfect wedding cake, and thank you for creating delicious desserts. Our guests could not stop talking about how much they loved the cupcakes and the mini pies.

Written By: Sherri Rodriguez

Betty Kay was the first and only cake bakery I met with and as soon I met her I knew she was the one to make our cake. She had the biggest variety of flavors and combinations that I’ve seen. She was so helpful and gave me all the different options I was considering and created a flavor plan based on our guest list, budget and style. She was very detailed and organized. I ended up doing a 3 tier cake and 2 different flavored cakes because I couldn’t decide what to choose! She gave me lots of options and I can’t decide on just one! We also had her do our favors - chocolate covered pretzels - and they were AMAZING!!! Everything was delivered seamlessly and they were all set up when we arrived on our wedding day. I will definitely always use Betty Kay for any event or cake I need! Thank you again!

Written By: Sibelle Sykes

Betty Kay was the bakery of our choice for our wedding cake from the recommendation of our wedding coordinator. I had read reviews of her cakes prior to our tasting/booking meeting and was very impressed. We had the choice of tasting 5 different combinations of cake and frosting or picking from a list of 80 different flavors. We chose to do a small 3-layer cake and sheet cakes in the flavor of our choice. We met with Betty in her home and she was very laid back, helpful, and enthusiastic. We chose a simple, but elegant cake design. On the day of the wedding the cake looked exactly as we had hoped and tasted amazing. We were very happy with our wedding cake. We also ordered some birthday cupcakes for my dad (he’s a big sweets fan) and they were equally as delicious!