Audreys Fine Baked Goods Review

A review of the experience of Audreys Fine Baked Goods written by Deedee Greer.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: 231 Montauk Hwy
city: West Sayville
state: NY
postalCode: 11796
latitude: 40.728199
longitude: -73.100685

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(631) 244-7288

The Reviews

Written By: Deedee Greer

We used Audrey’s Bakery for our NY wedding. We had cupcakes, a small cake for us to cut, and chocolate covered strawberries. EVERYTHING was excellent. The strawberries were especially a hit, we had none left over! Our wedding was in August and our contract stated that the colors for the decorations would be determined at a later date. We were given a box of frosting and sprinkles to try at home. When we had decided on our colors, we were told that the decorations would be different than what is in the box. We were fine with that, since we hadn’t actually seen them before. When the time came to order, we were given the option of ordering the decorations in the box, with a few exceptions. We had a choice of 3 sprinkles, and 3 different colored ribbons. We were ordering everything we had chosen for our wedding, so we chose red, green, and purple. When we actually showed up to the venue, the decorations in the box were totally different than what we ordered. We were given one set of sprinkles and one ribbon. The other color sprinkles and color ribbons weren’t at the store. We were told to just pick up what we needed when we ordered it. We did, and there was a $30 fee for bringing in 1 decoration package. That was fine, we actually ended up paying the fee, because we ended up ordering more decorations than what were in the box. When all was said and done, we were ordering a whole bunch of stuff we didn’t need, for a $30 fee. At the wedding, we were only shown the one ribbon we were supposed to get! It was like the people at Audrey’s just randomly picked the colors of everything. And they were all white. So, our cupcakes and our cake were both understated. But they both looked great! We asked if there was a particular shade of purple we could use, and we were told no, that everything was white. So, we were expecting a white ribbon, white cupcakes, and a white cake. Our cake was navy, our cupcakes were a different navy than the cake, and the ribbon was white. It didn’t match anything! So, our one star is for the actual decorations, because they were understated, when we were led to believe we would have overstated, over the top, decorations. But our 2 cupcakes and our cake were great, so our overall rating is 5 for everything else.

Written By: Elianore Aycock

We used Audrey’s for our June 2018 wedding, and they were an ABSOLUTE PLEASURE to work with! We were planning our wedding from a distance (nearly 3 hours away), and Audrey’s made the process so easy and fun! They were so helpful and willing to answer any questions or help with anything! They made our wedding planning experience one of the best parts of planning a wedding! They made us feel at home and well cared for! Now that the wedding is over, they made beautiful cupcakes for us on our 1 year anniversary, and even made our wedding cake in a different flavor for our anniversary (the original flavor was to die for, by the way, and the new anniversary cake was delicious as well!). We can’t thank them enough or recommend them enough to anyone that is planning a wedding, or needs baked goods to help make their special event happen! Thanks Audrey’s!

Written By: Elspeth Hardin

We used Audreys for our NY wedding, and it was really a pleasure to work with them. They had us into their bakery for a tasting, brought out samples of their different types of cakes, and helped us choose the flavors we wanted. We really appreciated how they worked with us to make sure we had what we wanted, but without making too many changes to the original design we had in mind. One of the nice features of using Audreys is that we didn’t have to worry about saving money on the size of the cake, since they include a free smaller 2nd tier in the price if your wedding is within their defined time frame. We were married in the summer, and our wedding was within the given timeframe, so we got the entire 3 tier cake free. We paid only for the decorations and sugar flowers we wanted, which was very reasonable. The cake was delicious, and I plan on using them again for our annual holiday cake!