Beach Bakery Cafe Review

A review of the experience of Beach Bakery Cafe written by Celle Davies.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: 112 Main St
city: Westhampton Beach
state: NY
postalCode: 11978
latitude: 40.809946
longitude: -72.642956

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(631) 288-6552

The Reviews

Written By: Christan Stuart

We used the Westhampton Beach location for our June wedding. I used to live in NH and have visited the Beach Bakery many times. The beach really does have some of the most amazing treats (in addition to their amazing cakes). The staff was amazing - I met with two vendors and once I decided on the cake and cupcakes, it was basically set in stone (ha ha). The presentation of all the cupcakes was amazing - each one had a little cupcake made of fondant that matched the flavor. The cupcakes were a hit! We had 6 flavors to choose from - and the flavors were unlike any cupcake I have ever tasted (I am not a huge sweets person so I love cupcakes). The cake was also AMAZING - the perfect cake does exist! Not too sweet, very fresh, very moist and very flavorful. Our cake was so fresh we could still smell it when we cut the cake! The cupcakes were amazing and it was so hard to choose which flavor to choose as each one was amazing as well. The cake was also perfect and each layer was different and very flavorful. I have been to many weddings and I have never left a wedding very happy - but this is definitely one of the best cakes I have ever had and our wedding guests are still talking about it! Thank you so much Beach Bakery - you made our day even more special!

Written By: Jobye Swanson

We got our wedding cake from the cafe, its really good there. The bakery made the cake just the way we wanted it and delivered it to the cafe. We got the flavors of our choice and they were all great. I just wish we would have had more to eat of it! We only got to try it on our wedding day and then some how the top tier got away from us! I called the bakery a few times and they told me they where looking for it, I even got on a wait list. Its been 6 months and we still don’t have it!! I will say they do credit you for the top tier if you call and show them a picture of your cake. I called and they where going to send me a check for the difference but it never came!! I tried to call a few times and they would just send me to the list, so at this point I think its better to call them than just to wait!! I still haven’t gotten my check or credit for my top tier!!