A Spoon Fulla Sugar Review

A review of the experience of A Spoon Fulla Sugar written by Elenore Golden.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Cakes & Desserts:
- Cake Accessories:
  - Cake Stands
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom’s Cakes
Price Range:
- $$ – Affordable

Location

address1: 11916 Montgomery Road
city: Cincinnati
state: OH
postalCode: 45249
latitude: 39.28065
longitude: -84.3252

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(513) 683-0444

The Reviews

Written By: Elenore Golden

I was fortunate enough to be introduced to A Spoon Fulla Sugar at the Taste of Cincinnati event this past October. The samples were amazing and it was an easy decision to set up a cake tasting and selection appointment.

We ended up ordering a small wedding cake and a variety of cupcakes. Our wedding cake was simple, as we just wanted a small cake to cut and share with our immediate family. At the cake tasting, we were provided with a variety of cakes, fillings and frostings. We ended up selecting a white cake with raspberry filling and cream cheese frosting. When I asked about adding color, their response was “We add what ever color you want!” It was a simple ivory colored cake with fresh raspberry decorations.

For our cupcakes, we selected four different flavors. They were all absolutely delicious! We ended up with lemon cake with blueberry mouse filling and lemon frosting, carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, peanut butter cake with honey buttercream and chocolate cake with peanut butter and chocolate buttercream fillings and frosting. We also ordered a topper cake as described below.

The next day, we went back to their shop to see the lovely Shani and discuss the variety of cupcake flavors. We selected a two-tiered heart shaped cake as our topper cake. We then discussed different colors and decorations for our top heart. As the wedding date drew closer, we were emailed different ideas and a price estimate. On the day of the wedding, the cake was delivered on time and was set up perfectly.

The day was hectic, but we were able to sneak in and get a few cupcake bites. They were so delicious! I was also able to take a picture of the cake, so you can see how beautiful it was! It was a simple and elegant heart with our initials. The frosting had our initial “N” and “E” in fondant with a pearl border.

Overall, we were so happy with how everything turned out. We still continue to get compliments on the cupcakes. We have even been told they are trying to book them for their own wedding!

We are so happy we selected A Spoon Fulla Sugar for our special day. It was so easy to set up an appointment, taste and select different flavors. They were so helpful and brought our ideas to life! We were so happy with the heart shaped cake and it was all so delicious! We cannot wait to eat the top heart in a year!

I would highly recommend A Spoon Fulla Sugar! You will not be disappointed with their flavors, service or presentation for your event.

Written By: Liana Rowland

We used A Spoon Fulla Sugar for our wedding cake and grooms cake and it was one of the best decisions we made! Their cakes are incredibly yummy and our cakes looked and tasted just like we planned.

We had a four tier cake and we were able to choose two flavors for each tier. We chose amaretto orange with chocolate chips and chocolate peanut butter with Oreo cookies. We also had red velvet with cream cheese. Everyone loved the cake and I can’t wait to eat the top tier on our anniversary!

I showed A Spoon Fulla Sugar a picture of what we wanted our cake to look like and it looked even better than the picture we found on Pinterest! My husband also requested a woodblock pattern in gray on a gray cake and it was the look he was going for and it looked amazing.

A Spoon Fulla Sugar is incredibly easy to work with and we had no issues at all with our cakes! They are incredibly reasonable with pricing on wedding cakes and we were very happy with our results. We absolutely loved the cake and we can’t wait to order one for our anniversary!

Written By: Maribelle Boyle

We used A Spoon Fulla Sugar for our wedding cake and favors (chocolate chip cookies). We got so many compliments about our cake and cookies! Emily was so great to work with and she helped us decide on flavors and designs for our cake. She created the perfect cake and it was not only beautiful, but so good! We chose to do cupcakes for our wedding so we also got some yummy cupcakes as well. So good! Our wedding cake was so good, my husband and I decided to eat the top of our cake, we had a smaller wedding and we wanted to have a slice of our cake to take home with us. (Who doesn’t want that?) Well, we had no problem eating a piece of cake that was wrapped in tin foil. (No one saw that we did that.) Once we got the cake out of the box at home, we had no problem eating it. It was that good. :) Overall, we had a great experience and I would highly recommend them. We will be using them for our future cookie and cake needs.

Written By: Annamaria Starr

We ordered a small cake from A Spoon Fulla Sugar for our wedding cake and it was SO delicious! Our entire wedding group loved it, especially the chocolate lovers in our group :)

The owner, Christine, was wonderful to work with! I sent her a couple of photos of wedding cakes I liked and she designed a cake that was exactly what I was looking for. She even ordered the cake tags for me since they were not a part of the template she had made for the cake.

When we had a little over a week left before our wedding, she was so kind to suggest a cake testing. We picked a flavor we hadn’t tried, she made it for us on a weekend we were available, and then she packaged up two other flavors we picked and sent them to our apartment. The chocolate peanut butter was my favorite :)

Thank you so much for making our wedding cake so beautiful and yummy!