Buttercream Bakery Review

A review of the experience of Buttercream Bakery written by Matilda Payne.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Price Range:
- $$ – Affordable

Location

address1: 1416 Buttermilk Ave.
city: Columbus
state: OH
postalCode: 43235
latitude: 40.10965
longitude: -83.055743

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(614) 570-8358

The Reviews

Written By: Elnora Hamrick

Buttercream made my wedding cake for our 10/21/19 wedding at the Lake Club. They did an amazing job with the design and the flavors! We were able to taste a few of the flavors ahead of time, and WOW so many to choose from. We were able to choose up to 5! We went with the white chocolate Raspberry, the chocolate espresso, and the lemon with rasberry filling. With our larger cake round and larger round, we had enough to serve 80-100 people. We had such a hard time choosing which flavor to choose, that we decided to have a tasting party with some family and close friends, and we bought some cupcakes to try the flavors too! Buttercream was very professional, and was so helpful with my cake design and helping me choose my colors and design. They made the cake rounds look so beautiful, and they were so helpful with setting the rounds on the cakes. We had a blast at our tasting party, and we all decided this was the best cake ever! The day of our wedding was a breeze, Buttercream set the cake rounds and made the cake look gorgeous! The cake tasted amazing and everyone loved it! We were extremely happy with our cake and buttercream! Thank you guys so much!

Written By: Amabelle Branch

We found our cake designer at a bridal show, and immediately we fell in love with her cakes and designs! Her icing is to die for, and she was the one of the only cake designers who believed in our wedding cake idea of a cookie cake. She showed us a picture of a cookie cake she had designed, and it looked amazing.

We had a great time meeting with her and talking about ideas. She was very open to our crazy ideas, and was very helpful and patient with our ideas. We had a cookie cake bar at our wedding, and it was a huge hit! Everyone loved it, and it added that special something extra we were looking for.

Her pricing for what we wanted was very reasonable, and she worked with us for the best price possible. She did not try to up-charge us for any unreasonable thing, and was very straightforward with what we could do and in the price range we wanted.

The cake was to die for, her designs are wonderful, and we loved working with her. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a great tasting cake, with decorations to die for, and great prices!