Batter Up Cake Company Review

A review of the experience of Batter Up Cake Company written by Shirline Diaz.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

city: Dayton
state: OH
postalCode: 45417
latitude: 39.741893
longitude: -84.260881

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(937) 269-2741

The Reviews

Written By: Shirline Diaz

I cannot say enough good things about Batter Up! and their wonderful wedding cakes. First, the cake tasting was stress free, informative, and not over charging like most other places. They worked with our budget and our cake was gorgeous and most important it tasted amazing. Our guests raved about the cake and how beautiful it was and how delicious it was. We had a chocolate lover and they worked around that and made him a special chocolate grooms cake that was a hit. We had the traditional flavors of fudge, raspberry, and brown sugar, and a new flavor they are promoting witch is orange creamsicle. It is a unique taste that all people love. I can’t wait for our first anniversary so we can enjoy it again. I highly recommend Batter Up! for any event, not just weddings.

Written By: Rochelle Howe

I’ll be the first to admit I’m far from a native Daytonian, but I’ll be returning for all things Sugaree.

It wasn’t until I was planning my own wedding that I realized the importance of dessert in weddings. So many weddings I’ve been to over the years have been the bare minimum in this department, and I can’t even count the number of times I’ve been to a wedding where the cake was stunning and the dessert table was an afterthought. It just wasn’t a priority, and it shouldn’t be.

I’m also not a fan of cake, so we really needed an alternative to a wedding cake, and who does better than Batter Up!? They did our wedding cake (doubles as a science fiction themed tier), a dessert table that even a picky man like me was happy with, and a grooms cake that was absolutely my favorite.

They were so easy to work with, responsive, and helpful, and I honestly can’t say enough good things about them. I’d also like to add here that they were very conscious of the cost of their products and services. They offered ideas for dessert alternatives, but never pressured us in any way. It was really refreshing to have a vendor that knows how to deliver on their promises, and Batter Up! is definitely a company that does exactly that.

If you’re looking for a wedding cake that’s more than just the standard almond cake with fruit filling, but also wants to support a local company that’s been around for decades, I’d highly recommend the Batter Up! staff.

Written By: Stella Boyd

We had a great experience with Batter Up! When we went in for our initial tasting, we were greeted with trays of different flavors of cake filled with various toppings and mousses. We were given a tour of the kitchen where we were able to see that they have many different displays set up that show off all of their different cake flavors and topping combinations. We got to take a few samples of each and were given an estimated cost for a cake and some estimated costs for some of the more popular combinations of toppings. We ended up going with a different combination than what was initially tested, but it was still yummy and everyone that got a piece raved about it! We had the initial cost for the cake reduced by about 25% when we put in the order and we still had left over cake after the wedding (more than we had expected). We were emailed a confirmation with all of the details a week before the wedding, and everything ran smoothly on the day of! The cake was delivered exactly when they said it would be and it was still yummy even though it was over a month old! We couldn’t have asked for a better experience or more delicious cake!