Baked by Shelly Review

A review of the experience of Baked by Shelly written by Stacie Mayo.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Price Range:
- $ – Inexpensive

Location

address1: 3193 Guffey Dr
city: Grove City
state: OH
postalCode: 43123
latitude: 39.864547
longitude: -83.089308

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(614) 871-2851

The Reviews

Written By: Lib Singer

We LOVED our cake from Baked by Shelly! It was so beautiful and it tasted delicious. When we first met with Jan to design our cake, she had samples of the frostings and fillings to try. We actually decided our flavors by tasting them: white cake with a butter cream filling for me and chocolate cake with a fudge filling for my husband. I am not a big cupcake person, but the frosting and chocolate cake flavors are fantastic. I am also lactose intolerant and have a hard time finding dairy free cake, but Jan was able to make a yummy dairy free frosting for me. The frosting is not heavy at all and tastes great. The decoration of the cake was exactly what we wanted. I was a little worried that the colors on the cake would be hard to see during the wedding, but the colors came out great on the bright white frosting. The one problem we had was that we wanted to save the top tier of our cake for our one year anniversary, but the bakery didn’t save it for us. It would have been nice if they had given it to us or we could have asked our venue to save it for us. Other than that, I would 10/10 recommend this bakery!