Buehlers Review

A review of the experience of Buehlers written by Geri Cohen.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: 1401 Old Mansfield Road
city: Wooster
state: OH
postalCode: 44691
latitude: 40.804389
longitude: -81.961186

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(888) 283-4537

The Reviews

Written By: Geri Cohen

We used Buehler’s for our cake and cupcakes for our wedding. My husband and I are not huge cake eaters, but we knew we wanted something special and tasty for our wedding day. Buehler’s did not disappoint. We had a small cake for just the two of us, and the flavors were incredible. For our cupcakes, we had carrot cake, chocolate with chocolate filling, and vanilla with raspberry filling. Needless to say, our guests raved about the cupcakes. Their prices are also very reasonable. We had a small cake and about 5 dozen cupcakes, and it was under $250. The cost included not only the ingredients, but also the delivery and set up. They set the cupcakes up on cake stands and placed our topper and flowers on top. It was so beautiful that our guests didn’t even realize they were cupcakes and not a real cake! Everything was perfect and delicious, and it was very reasonably priced. They were also very helpful and patient with me in several different consultations because I wasn’t quite sure what I wanted. I am so glad we ended up choosing them, and I would highly recommend them to anyone!

Written By: Julita Fitzpatrick

I am not a huge cake person, and when I was first approached about wanting a cake for our wedding I figured a cake wouldn’t really be my thing. One of the main reasons I was originally attracted to getting a cake from here was that they make really nice mini cakes so that you can have a little bit of everything and then you can have as many flavors as you want. Well needless to say having a whole cake wasn’t my thing. I did a whole dessert table with cupcakes, cookies, and brownies and that’s what I wanted for my wedding. It all started with Buehler’s cake bake shop.

I went to this cake shop to try out their cupcakes and when I got there I saw a woman that I later learned was the cake baker. She sat down with me one on one and showed me all of the different types of deserts she could make and then she asked me what I liked. Well I love red velvet and I am a big chocolate fan. She showed me that she could do both and then she said that I could have different flavors in each tier of the cake so I could have my own custom cake. I was hooked and I knew that was exactly what I wanted. She showed me all the different types of cupcakes she could make and then she made me a whole cupcake tier that was all my flavors. It was all so delicious and I couldn’t stop eating it.

About a month before my wedding I went in to make sure that all the details were set in place. I also wanted to add some other small desserts that I wanted to be able to display on the cake table. When I went in to talk to her she told me that everything I wanted was no problem and she even asked me what else I wanted. Well needless to say I ended up with like 20 different mini desserts in different flavors. At that point I had to ask if we could have a bigger cake so I could have a traditional wedding cake just for me and my husband to cut. She was no problem with that and I knew they could make a cake big enough for all of my desserts. I was so excited and couldn’t wait to see our cake.

As we all know wedding planning has a tendence to make you crazy and before I knew it was the week of my wedding. I drove myself crazy going out to the cake shop just to drop off some decorations and then going back to drop off some more decorations. As I went back to drop off more decorations I started to notice that the first decoration I dropped off was starting to be covered by the second decoration I dropped off and there were some details that weren’t completed. This was all covered by the cake shop, but I noticed that their was some confusion on the details of our cake. However all of the details perminently fixed themselves and by the time I got to the cake shop to drop off my remaining decorations our cake was completely made and all set in place.

As I walked into the cake shop to see our cake for the first time I was so happy to see that all the details I wanted was and is still being done perfectly. I was so excited to see our cake that I decided to surprise my husband with a groom’s cake. I wanted to have a baseball cake made and I wanted to cover it with fondant so it looks better and you can actually eat it. When I went into the cake shop I told them I wanted a baseball cake and I wanted it to be able to be eaten. They were no problems with that and they actually made us a cake that looked really nice and actually tastes really good. They even made it in our wedding colors and it was really tasty.

Needless to say I love Buehlers and their treats and I couldn’t imagine going to any other cake shop. They have a great product and even if you don’t know what you want to have them help you figure out exactly what you want and then they will help you get all the details and they are very flexible and easy to work with. They have a great product and they are super people.