Bentleys Bakery Review

A review of the experience of Bentleys Bakery written by Ivett Hwang.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: Hummelstown
city: Hummelstown
state: PA
postalCode: 17036
latitude: 40.278114
longitude: -76.700731

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(717) 395-3461

The Reviews

Written By: Ivett Hwang

Wow, what more can I say. I had a wedding cake and cupcakes for my wedding on 9/29/19. The wedding cake was absolutely amazing. I wanted something simple yet elegant and modern. Bentleys Bakery didn’t disappoint. I got exactly what I wanted and it was beautiful! I also got another cake later on in the week or so before my wedding and decided to change that one too. So I got two cakes from Bentley’s Bakery - Yummy! I had a hard time choosing flavors because they were all so good. The cake was moist and held together perfectly. The buttercream frosting was smooth and not too sweet. The cupcakes were so good that my family wanted to take some home for themselves. I would definitely book Bentley’s Bakery again for any event and would recommend them for any occasion. The pricing is so good that I even got to have two cakes for the price of one! Yummy, beautiful cakes!

Written By: Annamaria Starr

I worked with Bentley’s Bakery and their team was nothing but amazing! They have a ton of different flavors to choose from, some of which are quite unique. The team was very helpful when we were trying to choose flavors and they even let us taste some of the more unique flavors (like Wasabi Ginger). They were very helpful throughout the planning process and made sure to explain exactly how things would be laid out on the cake. They made sure to get things right the first time. The cake was incredible! We received so many compliments on the unique flavors, the delicious cake, and of course the cute penguin toppers! Not only do they make delicious cakes, but they also make incredibly cute penguin toppers! I would highly recommend Bentley’s Bakery for any occasion!

Written By: Goldie Russell

We used Bentley’s Bakery for our wedding cake. We went with a smaller 3 tier cake and cake balls. We had cherry, red velvet and chocolate cake balls. Our cake was a chocolate cake with raspberry filling and vanilla icing. The cake balls are 1.50 each and the cake is.50 per slice. That being said, the cake was delicious, the cake balls are huge, and we got a lot of compliments. The only issue we had was we paid for delivery between 8-10am and they told us at 12 that they forgot, but called and it was okay. The cake balls weren’t delivered until 2. I had placed an order for 1 dozen each of the 3 flavors and had told them the order was for 2 weeks out, so I was expecting an order for 1 week out. I understand that the order may have gotten lost, but they knew the order was for 2 weeks out and did nothing. If you order, make sure you tell them the order is for 2 weeks out. I would still recommend them, just make sure to keep them in the loop if you are ordering far in advance.