Butter Maid Bakery Review

A review of the experience of Butter Maid Bakery written by Honor Blair.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

city: Pittsburgh
state: PA
postalCode: 44512
latitude: 40.442169
longitude: -79.994945

Email(s)

Phone number(s)

(330) 758-5968

The Reviews

Written By: Honor Blair

The wedding cake was so amazing! I really can’t say enough about how delicious the cake was! We had a 3 layer cake, the top and bottom layers were chocolate cake and the middle layer was vanilla cake…and all of this was covered in buttercream (that’s right…covered in butter). We also had a special surprise for my husband…a small 1 layer king cake that was wrapped in fondant and decorated like a king cake! (we both love king cake) The cake was so moist and delicious that we ate a slice of the left over cake every day for 2 weeks after the wedding! Not only was the cake delicious but it was also beautiful! Lisa helped us design our cake and she decorated it beautifully! She also helped us with deciding on flavors and she has so many to choose from! I highly recommend the team at Butter Maid Bakery for any wedding cake!

Written By: Orsa Stevens

We had Butter Maid Bakery create our wedding cake, and it was absolutely delicious! We did a variety of cupcakes for our guests, and a small, 6-inch cake for the wedding party. Our wedding party and family in general loved the cupcakes! The staff was very professional and helpful, and was willing to work with us on flavors and decorations (we had a theme: marbled cake with white chocolate frosting…). They created a custom cupcake stand out of wood, and it added to the rustic feel we were going for with our wedding. We even were able to rent a cupcake stand from them (all we had to do was return the stand to the bakery the day after our wedding). Our 6-inch cake was absolutely delicious (we chose chocolate cake with a raspberry jam filling…). We highly recommend Butter Maid Bakery!

Written By: Joly May

My husband and I had a fairly short engagement and I knew I wanted to do a nice cake tasting. Unfortunately, I live in California and was not able to go! Butter Maid Bakery was so kind as to offer to do a tasting box so I could have my mom and sister pick it up and try it out of my presence. They did 3 different flavors (vanilla/chocolate/spice) with a pound cake and a filling (they have many different flavors to choose from). It was delicious and I was so excited to bring it home and have some time to really enjoy it. I also decided to get a smaller cake so we could do a few different flavors. I was going to do one of my husbands favorite flavors, but decided against it after tasting the flavors with him. I ended up getting a sweet potato cake with cream cheese and cinnamon filling and pumpkin cake with cinnamon and pumpkin cream cheese filling. The cake was perfect and delicious! It also was very reasonably priced. I was looking at spending $600-700 on a wedding cake. The sweet potato cake was only $475. They were also very flexible on the size and shape as I wanted a 3 tier cake that was square instead of round like the rest of the cakes. It was a great experience and I would highly recommend Butter Maid Bakery for delicious cake and excellent customer service.