Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Colleyville Review

A review of the experience of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Colleyville written by Koren Lim.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

address1: 4712 Colleyville Blvd, Ste 160
city: Colleyville
state: TX
postalCode: 76034
latitude: 32.878662
longitude: -97.158282

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(817) 581-7437

The Reviews

Written By: Koren Lim

We had selected Colleyville as our venue for our wedding (thanks, KC!), and a friend of ours recommended Buttermilk Sky/Pie for our desserts. I’m so glad we went with them!

We ordered a variety of mini pies, mini cheesecakes, mini fruit tarts, and a variety of cookies. Everything was fantastic! The desserts were so incredibly reasonably-priced, and were more than I could imagine ever wanting or needing for a wedding. We ordered so much extra that we had desserts for days after the wedding!

The folks who own this business are so incredibly helpful and friendly, and they even came to the venue to set up the desserts. It was so nice to have one less thing to worry about! I would HIGHLY recommend this place to anyone looking for a great variety of desserts for any event. (In fact, my wife and I are booking a dinner with them right now for next weekend!!)

Written By: Marta Leonard

So, you know how Buttermilk Sky/Pie Shop makes the best pies in the world (as so many folks have told us - including the reporters for the Today Show and National Geographic TV, yikes!) - well, they make the best wedding cakes, too!

We were planning our wedding from OK, so a LOT of our communication was email based. They were so helpful and accommodating throughout the entire planning process - they even sent us 2 sample cakes, one with and one without the top layer, as we requested, so that we could try them at home, which is exactly what we wanted.

The day of the wedding, everything came out perfect and better than expected. The cake was beautiful (we went simple with a white cake) and the inside was as tasty as the wedding pie was wonderful. I can’t wait to have our anniversary pie! Thanks guys!!

Written By: Eva Riggs

We got married at Colleyville Country Club and were lucky enough to have them partner with Sky High to provide the desert portion of our meal. We are so glad we were able to experience their wonderful desert goods. We decided to have pie for our desert instead of cake, and Buttermilk Sky was so gracious to provide us with 6 (!) fresh pies of our choosing. We had a pie buffet set up at our desert table, so when it was time to eat we just grabbed one of the pies from the table and got to enjoy it at our table. They have so many delicious choices that we were able to have each person choose a favorite among their list of choices - Blackberry-Lemon, Buttermilk, Double Chocolate, and Pumpkin. Our guests were so gracious as to eat just the tops of their pies so that we could enjoy the pies all to ourselves! We had so much fun building our pie table and have so many great memories of our desert experience.