Blue Sugar Cookie Co. Review

A review of the experience of Blue Sugar Cookie Co. written by Leontine Song.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Location

city: Orange Grove
state: TX
postalCode: 78372
latitude: 27.956533
longitude: -98.035511

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(713) 597-2260

The Reviews

Written By: Leontine Song

I am a relative of a friend and so was able to get an entire dozen cookies free (worth every single penny). My husband and I really did not want to go to all the trouble of freezing the cookies and thawing them to do the tasting so we ordered 4 dozen cookies a week before the wedding. I called the bakery and asked for “Lisa”. They gave me her number and she was very helpful. She gave us TONS of cookies to taste and pick out which ones we wanted for the wedding. We chose 4 different kinds and they were all amazing. We chose the flavors and then about 3 weeks before the wedding we decided to change the design for the cookies. We sent her our new design and she was very helpful. She confirmed everything and then asked us how we wanted the cookies delivered. We chose a time and she was very helpful again. The day before the wedding we decided that we wanted each cookie to have a mini key lime pie on top. She confirmed that they could do that and she was very helpful yet again. The day of the wedding the pies were delivered and on to the cookie table they went. Everyone got a flavor of their choosing and the pies on top. The whole table was gorgeous. The cookies were soft and chewy, the key lime pies were delicious and the graham crackers were perfect. I will definitely be using them again.

Written By: Odele Jernigan

I wanted to do a wedding cake that wasn’t a traditional white cake with flowers, designs, etc. I wanted more of a ‘Wedding’ theme. I was thinking of doing small cakes or cupcakes in different colors with icing and then put a wedding ‘cake’ on top.

I found this place on The Knot website and they created a cake that was exactly what I wanted! I sent them some photos of wedding cakes that I liked and they created one that was so similar to what I wanted it was crazy! I was so excited when I saw it and it tasted amazing!!! We chose a ‘naked cake’ with fudge, peanut butter, and cream cheese filling. It was to die for!!! The cake was a huge hit and I got so many compliments on it!!! It was so good that we didn’t have any to take home…..

The people were so nice, easy to work with, and extremely talented. They also gave me a discount since they did work for My venue (Broken Arrow Resort & Casino).

I highly recommend them for any cake needs, not just wedding cakes!!!

Written By: Modestia Reilly

I went to a bridal show early in my planning process and one of the vendors I was able to schedule a tasting with was Blue Sugar. Let me tell you, all the cake samples that were out for me were AMAZING! Everything was perfect and delicious (I really should have taken pictures). They were one of the few vendors that actually offered a variety of flavors rather than just a handful of cake flavors. They offer so many delicious flavors that you will have a hard time deciding which ones to use for your cake, but that is I think the whole charm of using a cookie company for your wedding cake. They were so excited to help me create the perfect cake that I ended up booking with them before I even had a wedding! They were very responsive via phone and email. On my wedding day, they delivered everything that was promised and the cake was even better than I could have imagined. The best part of all of this is that after my husband and I eat our complimentary first year anniversary cake, they will make us a new cake for the next year in our flavor of choice!!! How sweet is that! I would highly recommend Blue Sugar to anyone who is looking for a wedding cake vendor.

Written By: Emmye Barr

We chose blue sugar because they are local and make great cakes. The owners are great to work with they are very informative and when we had a question they answered it and didn’t leave us wondering. We chose the lavender cake with lemon curd filling and had it both ways, with a white cake and chocolate ganache filling and it was amazing. I usually am not too fond of wedding cakes because of all the fondant but this cake was honestly just as good, if not better, than if it was all fondant. It was so moist and the lavender was just perfect, again if it was all fondant it would have been perfect but it wasn’t necessary with the cake it self. It was delicious and it was just what we wanted. It was delivered on time and everything looked great. They are a little on the expensive side but they are worth it and honestly it was all worth it.