Aggies Bakery and Cake Shop Review

A review of the experience of Aggies Bakery and Cake Shop written by Jillane Griffin.

Updated October 10, 2021

Basic Information

Owner: Rachel Schmidbauer

What do they offer?

Wedding Cakes

Features

Business Attributes:
- Women-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts:
- Cake Accessories:
  - Cake Stands
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom’s Cakes
Price Range:
- $$$ – Moderate

Location

address1: 7328 W Greenfield Ave
city: West Allis
state: WI
postalCode: 53214
latitude: 43.016654
longitude: -88.004274

Service Area: We travel within 45 miles from our bakery location

Email(s)

[email protected]

Phone number(s)

(414) 482-1288

The Reviews

Written By: Shayne Coleman

Aggie’s Bakery made my cake for our wedding and it turned out exactly how I envisioned! They worked with me to change the height of the cake a little bit, so that I could put my husbands and my initials on it! (we had an initial perch on our wedding cake LOL) The cake was sooo yummy! We had a variety of flavors. They had sooo many flavors to choose from. I was a little worried that some of them were very unusual, but they did not have any strange flavors! They were great to work with! They were so organized! They called to keep me up date on everything! I had a cake tasting and they gave me all the flavors of cake’s and icing’s that I wanted to try! The day of the wedding, they delivered the cake and put the fresh flowers that were left for the cake on the cake, and it turned out so pretty! I loved it! They were so helpful! I highly recommend Aggie’s Bakery! They are a great bakery! They are very professional! I give them a 5 star rating! :)

Written By: Ingaberg Kennedy

We ordered our DJ Steve’s cake from Aggie’s for our April 2021 wedding, and it was the most delicious cake I’ve ever had.

We did the almond cake with champagne buttercream frosting, and it was so light and fluffy. I also loved that we had so many options with flavors and fillings. My favorite was the champagne buttercream frosting.

The cake was so delicious that I had dreams about it, and I’m not even a cake person! The day after the wedding, my new husband and I sat down and had a slice of the leftover cake, and it was delicious even then!

We had Aggie’s do a simple design with some fresh flowers, and it was beautiful.

My brother and sister-in-law previously used Aggie’s for their wedding cake, and I’m so glad we got to enjoy the same delicious cake!